Brooklyn College MFA Students Sue NYC and Mayor Bloomberg
PRESS RELEASE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
For press inquiries or
to view a copy of the complaint, contact:
Marni Kotak
marnikotak@yahoo.com
917-692-1938
Brooklyn College MFA Students Sue NYC and Mayor Bloomberg
for Shut Down Art Show
Suit Filed Against City of New York, NYC Parks Department and Brooklyn College for First Amendment Violations and Property Damage
NEW YORK (June 15, 2006) This morning the 18 graduating MFA students from Brooklyn College, whose thesis exhibition at the Brooklyn War Memorial was shut down by NYC officials last month, filed suit against the City of New York, the NYC Parks Department and Brooklyn College, citing First Amendment violations and property damages.
The case was filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York by their attorneys Norman Siegel and Steven Hyman of McLaughlin and Stern this morning. Plaintiffs in the case are all eighteen of the graduating MFA students with student Zoe Cohen, former President of the Brooklyn College Graduate Art Student Union, as the lead Plaintiff. Also joining the suit as a Plaintiff is Brooklyn Graduate Art Deputy and Professor of Art, Karin Giusti.
Named as Defendents are the City of New York, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, New
York City Parks and Recreation Department, NYC Parks Commissioner Adrian Benepe,
Brooklyn Borough Parks Commissioner Julius Speigel, and Brooklyn College
of the City University of New York.
The students’ attorney, former Executive Director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, Norman Siegel, states “The free expression of the artistic voice is an interest that demands full protection. A clear message must be sent that government is not the appropriate body to judge the value of art. The Bloomberg Administration and Brooklyn College should not try to impose an artistic orthodoxy on the City. Surely, such a phenomenon would be an anathema to freedom of expression -- part of New York City's cherished heritage."
The eighteen students are satisfied to file the lawsuit, claiming that it is necessary for them to stand up to this violation of their First Amendment rights, and declare that City government should not be allowed to abuse its authority by attempting to prohibit the nature of content exhibited in public spaces, and that censorship should not be allowed to thrive in the City of New York.
Furthermore, the students want Brooklyn College to be held responsible for any damages which resulted from the institution’s unauthorized removal of their work from the Brooklyn War Memorial space. “Art students’ work needs to be respected by their colleges and protected by the First Amendment rights which protect all creative expression,” student Zoe Cohen states. “We need to hold Brooklyn College and the City Government accountable for their actions.”
The other Plaintiffs in the case are Carla Aspenberg, Jill Auckenthaler, John Avelluto, David Davron, Susan C. Dessel, Carl James Ferrero, Carrie Fucile, Pamela Gordon, Yejin Jun, Diane Kosup, Marni Kotak, Augusto Marin, Akiko Mori, Christopher Moss, Sarah Phillips, Megan Piontkowski and Tamas Veszi.
Press Availability Today
Students and their attorneys will be available to meet with the press or take interviews from 2-4pm at the offices of McLaughlin and Stern, 260 Madison Avenue (betw. 38th and 39th), 20th Floor. For more information, contact: Marni Kotak, 917-692-1938, marnikotak@yahoo.com.
Background
The student show, Plan B, mounted as a graduation requirement for the 2006 Master of Fine Arts Degree at Brooklyn College of the City University of New York, was suddenly shut down at about 3:30PM on Thursday, May 4, 2006, by Brooklyn Borough Parks Commissioner, Julius Spiegel, who deemed the work not “appropriate for families.” On Monday, May 8, Brooklyn College removed the students’ artwork from the Brooklyn War Memorial without their permission, damaging some of the works. On May 24, the students held the re-opening of their exhibition, titled Plan B Prevails, at 70 Washington Street, in Dumbo, Brooklyn. The exhibition closes tomorrow, June 16th; gallery hours are Weds-Sun, 12-6pm.
For further information on the developing story of Plan B and Plan C, visit http://plancensored.blogspot.com.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
For press inquiries or
to view a copy of the complaint, contact:
Marni Kotak
marnikotak@yahoo.com
917-692-1938
Brooklyn College MFA Students Sue NYC and Mayor Bloomberg
for Shut Down Art Show
Suit Filed Against City of New York, NYC Parks Department and Brooklyn College for First Amendment Violations and Property Damage
NEW YORK (June 15, 2006) This morning the 18 graduating MFA students from Brooklyn College, whose thesis exhibition at the Brooklyn War Memorial was shut down by NYC officials last month, filed suit against the City of New York, the NYC Parks Department and Brooklyn College, citing First Amendment violations and property damages.
The case was filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York by their attorneys Norman Siegel and Steven Hyman of McLaughlin and Stern this morning. Plaintiffs in the case are all eighteen of the graduating MFA students with student Zoe Cohen, former President of the Brooklyn College Graduate Art Student Union, as the lead Plaintiff. Also joining the suit as a Plaintiff is Brooklyn Graduate Art Deputy and Professor of Art, Karin Giusti.
Named as Defendents are the City of New York, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, New
York City Parks and Recreation Department, NYC Parks Commissioner Adrian Benepe,
Brooklyn Borough Parks Commissioner Julius Speigel, and Brooklyn College
of the City University of New York.
The students’ attorney, former Executive Director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, Norman Siegel, states “The free expression of the artistic voice is an interest that demands full protection. A clear message must be sent that government is not the appropriate body to judge the value of art. The Bloomberg Administration and Brooklyn College should not try to impose an artistic orthodoxy on the City. Surely, such a phenomenon would be an anathema to freedom of expression -- part of New York City's cherished heritage."
The eighteen students are satisfied to file the lawsuit, claiming that it is necessary for them to stand up to this violation of their First Amendment rights, and declare that City government should not be allowed to abuse its authority by attempting to prohibit the nature of content exhibited in public spaces, and that censorship should not be allowed to thrive in the City of New York.
Furthermore, the students want Brooklyn College to be held responsible for any damages which resulted from the institution’s unauthorized removal of their work from the Brooklyn War Memorial space. “Art students’ work needs to be respected by their colleges and protected by the First Amendment rights which protect all creative expression,” student Zoe Cohen states. “We need to hold Brooklyn College and the City Government accountable for their actions.”
The other Plaintiffs in the case are Carla Aspenberg, Jill Auckenthaler, John Avelluto, David Davron, Susan C. Dessel, Carl James Ferrero, Carrie Fucile, Pamela Gordon, Yejin Jun, Diane Kosup, Marni Kotak, Augusto Marin, Akiko Mori, Christopher Moss, Sarah Phillips, Megan Piontkowski and Tamas Veszi.
Press Availability Today
Students and their attorneys will be available to meet with the press or take interviews from 2-4pm at the offices of McLaughlin and Stern, 260 Madison Avenue (betw. 38th and 39th), 20th Floor. For more information, contact: Marni Kotak, 917-692-1938, marnikotak@yahoo.com.
Background
The student show, Plan B, mounted as a graduation requirement for the 2006 Master of Fine Arts Degree at Brooklyn College of the City University of New York, was suddenly shut down at about 3:30PM on Thursday, May 4, 2006, by Brooklyn Borough Parks Commissioner, Julius Spiegel, who deemed the work not “appropriate for families.” On Monday, May 8, Brooklyn College removed the students’ artwork from the Brooklyn War Memorial without their permission, damaging some of the works. On May 24, the students held the re-opening of their exhibition, titled Plan B Prevails, at 70 Washington Street, in Dumbo, Brooklyn. The exhibition closes tomorrow, June 16th; gallery hours are Weds-Sun, 12-6pm.
For further information on the developing story of Plan B and Plan C, visit http://plancensored.blogspot.com.
posted by Plan C at 11:46 AM
102 comments
